The Buzz

All markets and investing news all the time

Taxpayers are subsidizing CEO pay

April 24, 2014: 12:05 PM ET
Howard Schultz Starbucks

Howard Schultz received $236 million in performance pay in 2012-13.

It's hard not to feel a little jealous -- even outraged -- looking at the latest list of the highest paid CEOs in America. The top 12 all made over $20 million last year.

But there's another reason to get upset when CEOs make millions: Taxpayers are subsidizing some of this wealth.

Stock options are one of the biggest drivers of high CEO pay these days.

The idea is to give executives stock to incentivize them to do well -- as the company does better, the stock does better, and the pay of these head honchos rises.

Here's the catch: Stock options for CEOs of publicly traded companies can be deducted from the corporation's U.S. tax bill.

Related: The highest-paid CEOs in America

So when Starbucks (SBUX) paid its chief Howard Schultz $236 million in "performance pay" in 2012 and 2013, it received about $82 million in tax credits, according to a report released Tuesday by the left-leaning Institute for Policy Studies.

Other highlights from the report, which focused specifically on the restaurant industry, include:

  • Chipotle (CMG) gave out close to $200 million in performance pay to its CEO in 2012-13, generating $69 million in tax breaks.
  • The head of Taco Bell, KFC and Pizza Hut owner Yum! Brands (YUM) received $67 million in stock options in the past two years, which translated to a $23 million tax bill discount.
  • McDonald's (MCD) handed out over $34 million in CEO stock options in the last two years, for a taxpayer subsidy of just over $12 million.

The "performance pay" trend took off after Congress changed the tax rules in 1993 to allow publicly traded companies to deduct an unlimited amount of executive stock option pay from their tax bills. Many corporations responded by increasing this kind of compensation, especially as the market roared in the late 1990s.

"CEO pay growth was very dramatic during the tech boom. It's all about options in the U.S. The reason it didn't happen in other countries is that option compensation was not available or illegal," says Kelly Shue, an assistant professor at the University of Chicago Booth School of Business who studies executive compensation.

While the public is often astonished at CEO pay levels, especially compared to what an average worker at the company earns, companies argue that performance pay is much better than simply handing out large base salaries. The stock options are akin to a bonus, and they could be worth a lot less if the stock goes down.

"Executive compensation at Starbucks is linked directly to company performance," notes company spokesman Jim Olson. "In the six years since Howard [Schultz] returned to Starbucks since the height of the financial crisis, our stock has grown more than 900%. Our market cap has gone from $5 billion to about $57 billion."

Chipotle, Yum and McDonald's did not comment for this article, but the National Restaurant Association, the umbrella organization for fast food and other restaurant chains, called the Institute for Policy Studies report a "mischaracterization" of the industry and notes that it fails to highlight all the opportunities available for restaurant workers.

Starbucks, for example, offers full and part-time workers health care plans and 401(k) retirement options.

"We have a legacy of putting our partners – how we refer to our employees – putting them first," says Olson.

Stock options have come under increasing scrutiny since the Dodd-Frank Act has required greater disclosure of CEO pay to shareholders and the public. The law went a step further with a "say on pay" provision to allow shareholders to have some oversight of executive pay.

Related: 4 ways to defend executive pay under the say on pay law

Shareholders of Oracle (ORCL), for example, have voted against the pay package for CEO Larry Ellison twice. Ellison often tops America's highest paid CEO list.

The problem is the shareholder vote is non-binding, so the vote is a mere public rebuke, which only goes so far. Shareholders would have to vote to change the company's board members if they really wanted to have an impact on CEO pay since boards have the final authority on executive compensation.

In Washington, there's increasing political will to take action on performance pay.

Congressman Dave Camp (R-Michigan) who chairs the House Ways and Means Committee, has put forward a comprehensive tax reform plan that would repeal the tax deduction for CEO performance pay.

Related: How to tame skyrocketing CEO pay

According to a summary of the proposed tax change by the Ways and Means Committee, some lawmakers are concerned that executives could "manipulate quarterly results" to boost their stock option compensation instead of focusing on "the long term success of the company."

Repealing the performance pay deduction rule would increase U.S. tax revenues by $12.1 billion over the next decade, according to estimates from Congress' Joint Committee on Taxation.

That wouldn't go very far toward narrowing America's deficit, but it would be one less taxpayer giveaway to big corporations.

  • Do consumers care about the debt ceiling?

    The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Paul R. La Monica. Other than Time Warner, the parent of CNNMoney, Abbott Laboratories and AbbVie, La Monica does not own positions in any individual stocks.

    The government's in shutdown mode? The U.S. may default on its debt? Yawn. Get me another almond milk pumpkin spice latte and spelt blueberry muffin please! And I think I'll go grab some carnitas tacos MORE

    - Oct 15, 2013 12:43 PM ET
  • Is Howard Schultz of Starbucks the best CEO ever?

    The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Paul R. La Monica. Other than Time Warner, the parent of CNNMoney, Abbott Laboratories and AbbVie, La Monica does not own positions in any individual stocks.

    With all due respect to the late Steve Jobs, Henry Ford, Sam Walton and Ray Kroc, Starbucks (SBUX) CEO Howard Schultz may be the best CEO ever.

    Sure, the former heads of Apple (AAPL), Ford (F), MORE

    - Sep 12, 2013 11:16 AM ET
  • Starbucks percs up: Stock jumps 4%

    Starbucks is enjoying a caffeine rush on Friday after the coffee king reported its latest quarterly results.

    Shares of Starbucks (SBUX) were up 4% in late morning trading. The company announced Thursday afternoon that fiscal first-quarter sales jumped 11% from a year ago and hit a record of $3.8 billion. Earnings per share were up 14%.

    Although these numbers simply met analysts' forecasts, many investors were clearly impressed to see the company MORE

    - Jan 25, 2013 11:59 AM ET
  • Einhorn: Short Chipotle, go long GM

    Hedge fund manager David Einhorn's newest short target: Chipotle Mexican Grill (CMG).

    Greenlight Capital's Einhorn thinks Taco Bell, owned by Yum Brands (YUM), will eat Chipotle's lunch with its new Cantina-style menu.

    Chipotle was one of four stocks that Einhorn discussed during his presentation at the Value Investing Congress in New York. He also spelled out a case for why investors should buy General Motors (GM) and health insurer Cigna (CI). MORE

    - Oct 2, 2012 12:56 PM ET
  • Green Mountain surges. But why?

    Green Mountain Coffee Roasters (GMCR) issued some decaf guidance. But that didn't matter to investors. Shares popped nearly 30% Thursday morning even though the company provided a near-term earnings outlook Wednesday that was less than stellar. It appears investors are excited to hear that the company is boosting its inventory ahead of what it hopes will be strong demand next year.

    That's dangerous. Many companies have been burned by boosting inventory MORE

    - Aug 2, 2012 10:41 AM ET
  • Starbucks cools off

    Starbucks is cooling off ... for now.

    The Seattle-based coffee chain trimmed its earnings forecast by about 2 cents a share Tuesday, but there's no need to panic. It's not like Starbucks is going to report a loss.

    Last year's high coffee prices, Europe's nagging debt problems and the company's baking plans will cut into Starbucks' bottom line this year, said chief financial officer Troy Alstead, at the annual stock conference of MORE

    - Jun 12, 2012 3:39 PM ET
  • Best of StockTwits: Not feeling like a million Starbucks

    Traders debate whether the Starbucks (SBUX) Bay Bread/La Boulange buy is a half-baked idea. And Netflix (NFLX) decides to show some backbone.

    JeffReevesIP: I just don't get the $SBUX bakery move. Yes, some Starbucks coffee drinkers may buy a pastry too. But is that the extent of the "plan?"

    JeffReevesIP: Bigger issue: I ADORE coffee but more & more don't - esp younger energy drink crowd. Yes $SBUX must rethink "cafe" menu MORE

    - Jun 5, 2012 2:00 PM ET
  • Stupid Stock Move of the Day! No Panera sell-off?

    #StupidStock Move of the Day! Was tempted to go $SBUX but yesterday's rally equally dumb. Still, $PNRA flat? Shouldn't Panera be nervous?— Paul R. La Monica (@LaMonicaBuzz) June 05, 2012

    Starbucks (SBUX) is getting into the bread business. While the $100 million purchase of La Boulange Bakery in San Francisco is a relatively small deal for the king of coffee, I am a little surprised Panera (PNRA) investors aren't more worried MORE

    - Jun 5, 2012 1:02 PM ET
  • Starbucks: 'We are bakers too'

    Starbucks is getting into the bread business.

    The Seattle-based coffee chain announced plans Monday to buy San Francisco-based Bay Bread and its La Boulange bakery brand for $100 million.

    "This is an investment in our core business," said Howard Schultz, Starbucks chief executive, in a conference call with financial analysts. "After more than 40 years, we will be able to say that we are bakers too."

    Schultz said one-third of Starbucks transactions include MORE

    - Jun 4, 2012 5:21 PM ET
Fear & Greed
Sponsored by

To view my watchlist

Not a member yet?

Sign up now for a free account
Stupid Stock Move of the Day
#StupidStock Move of the Day! Yes, $BBT earnings missed & there is FHA audit news. But down 4% when credit quality good and loans growing?
Powered by VIP.