Groupon will report its fourth-quarter earnings in two weeks. Is the worst over for the troubled daily deals stock?
One analyst seems to think so. Arvind Bhatia of Sterne Agee upgraded Groupon (GRPN) from "neutral" to "buy" on Wednesday morning. Shares popped 5% on the news.
Groupon has enjoyed a stellar run in recent months. The stock has more than doubled from the 52-week low it hit in November. But you have to put that rise in context. At about $5.50 a share, Groupon is still more than 80% below the all-time high of about $31 that shares hit shortly after Groupon's November 2011 initial public offering.
Several traders on StockTwits were not rushing to buy the Groupon hype.
Ouch. To be fair, Bhatia admits that the upgrade is controversial and a bit contrarian. He wrote in his note Wednesday that the upgrade was "not a call on the company's upcoming 4Q results." Bhatia bolded that phrase, not I. He added that "we recognize that meaningful risks remain, the stock will be volatile and we may be a bit early. However, we believe the risks are well known and largely priced in."
And to be honest, the only social media stock that really has proven to Wall Street that it has a viable business model with diversified revenue streams is LinkedIn (LNKD). I realize there's little (if anything) in common between Groupon and LinkedIn. But investors do seem to lump these two along with Facebook (FB), Zynga (ZNGA) and Yelp (YELP) in a broader social category.
One trader suggested that Groupon could have a fighting chance if recent mergers pan out.
It's possible. But it can be a rocky road for a recently public company to be making deals of its own. Just ask Zynga. OMGPop turned itno OMGFlop after people stopped drawing much of anything.
Another trader thought that Groupon had been punished so much that it may now be a bargain stock, particularly when compared to competitors.
Not so fast. Travelzoo (TZOO), which offers deals on airline and hotels, is trading at 18 times 2013 earnings estimates. Groupon, despite its lower share price, is trading at 23 times earnings forecasts. It's the more expensive stock of the two. That doesn't mean it is doomed to lag behind Travelzoo, but Groupon is not cheap.
And speaking of travel, one trader noted that Groupon's recommendation technology for trips seems far from perfect.
Too funny. It's kind of like the Pandora (P) Jack Johnson effect. No matter what station I seem to listen to, he always comes up. Led Zeppelin? Jack Johnson. John Coltrane? Jack Johnson. Toddler Radio for Baby Buzz? Jack Johnson playing songs from the Curious George movie soundtrack. I don't like Jack Johnson! And that's why I now use Spotify and Songza more than Pandora.
If Groupon is similarly unable to give its users what they really want, that doesn't bode well for future revenue and profits.
Not a member yet?Sign up now for a free account
|More than half of middle-class kids fail to earn bachelor's degrees|
|Samsung Galaxy S6: An iPhone for people who hate Apple|
|Stocks likely to fall further. Earnings stink|
|China's anti-corruption crackdown reaches U.S.|
|'Deliberate crash' a huge blow to Lufthansa|