The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Paul R. La Monica. Other than Time Warner, the parent of CNNMoney, Abbott Laboratories and AbbVie, La Monica does not own positions in any individual stocks.
There are only 30 stocks in the Dow. It's an exclusive club. So you'd think that getting kicked out of the Dow would be a bad sign for a company.
But that hasn't been the case for the three companies given the boot from the Dow last year.
Shares of Hewlett-Packard , which is in the news today after announcing it would split into two companies, are up more than 60% since it was told to not let the Dow door hit it on the way out in September 2013.
But the true standout is Alcoa. The stock has nearly doubled.
Alcoa has benefited from rising demand for aluminum. It also is a winner from Ford's (F) decision to use aluminum for the body of its latest F-150 truck. That should make the vehicle lighter and more fuel efficient.
Alcoa will report its third-quarter results Wednesday. Analysts expect profits to nearly double. It looks like Alcoa bulls can't wait!
And even though Alcoa should no longer be considered the official start to the earnings reporting period (out of respect for my colleague Mark Meinero, I will not use the term "season" since I know it's a pet peeve of his) some investors will still try and make Alcoa's earnings into something bigger than they really are out of sheer habit. (Sorry Catherine Tymkiw!)
Now does this mean that getting removed from the Dow is actually the cause of Alcoa's outperformance? Of course not.
It will be interesting to see if Alcoa, BofA and HP (or the HPs post split) can continue to do this well over the long haul. After all, they were removed with good reason. They were no longer as representative of the U.S. economy and stock market.
And there are plenty of examples of companies that were given the old heave-ho from the Dow and have languished since then. Citigroup (C) has lagged the Dow since it was given its walking papers in 2009. AIG (AIG) will probably never return to the heights it was at before the 2008 financial crisis caused it to be kicked out of the Dow.
Eastman Kodak was removed from the Dow in 2004. It eventually filed for bankruptcy. Sears (SHLD) has been in a long decline since its ouster from the Dow in 1997.
But for the past year at least, it didn't matter that Alcoa, HP and BofA are no longer included in the Dow. They are doing fine as more ordinary members of the S&P 500.
So it does look like a company can have a bright future as a Dow dropout. Now if only the same thing could be said for beauty school dropouts.
|With cameras banned, CNN sends sketch artist to White House briefing|
|White House-media relations at breaking point as Spicer searches for replacement|
|Here's how much it costs to be a wedding guest|
|How the GOP health care bills help the rich|
|Gwyneth Paltrow's Goop gets called out by NASA over healing stickers|